Eco Book Review: Do We Need Pandas – Thompson: 2010
‘The uncomfortable truth about Biodiversity’, he says….
Basically this book explains how looking to save just one species out of a whole ecosystem is not the way forward for saving biodiversity.
And to prove it, he opens up with an Introduction with an image of a Dodo. Are we ecologically worse off after we lost the Dodo as a species?
The Book Itself:
This book is a very easy to read description of how science works in practice. And that sometimes this results in ‘bad’ things.
The Author helps to explain even the simplest concepts about why biodiversity exists (usually due to a poor or limited environment) and how saving or losing key species can have disasterous consequences.
He also uses fantastic and sometimes unbelievable facts about species and habitats that were even a surprise to me after having read widely about these things. And he managed to put a new ‘twist’ on some already obvious facts with cited examples across the globe.
He is not out to ‘pick holes’ in conservation work or the studies of biodiversity across the globe; he just states statistical facts based on current figures that can’t really be argued with (although changes in our behaviour could always change the end results).
He also makes it clear that ‘saving the planet’ and it’s ecosystems and environments is a totally different science to ‘saving the panda’ or any single species or plot of land. Frighteningly he places an argument that we could easily and cheaply save nearly half of the worlds land surface which is currently ‘wildlands’ and where there are less than 5 humans per square kilometer.
But we don’t (or haven’t yet) as they aren’t really ‘worth’ anything to us and have very low biodiversity.
However the services they could provide (for free) for humans is priceless – but we seem to want to save every species rather than just the habitats they live in.
I totally agree that our actions are a tiny bit selfish – in general we want to save cute pandas and butterflies more than pristine but ‘boring’ plains and tundra – but he lets us know that this is quite a good option for saving ourselves. After all, we can’t live on this planet if there is no food or clean water for us all.
Result: 5/5
I couldn’t put this book down! I loved every page and every fact!
It is a reasonably small book too which made for great readability – as you knew it wouldn’t take long to glean all his wonderful and truthful facts from.
I work in one of the environments that he discusses in the book, and he certainly showed me a different side to it – as well as a new look at the principles of evolution and indicator species too.
He has also written a few others books that I can’t wait to get my hands on…..
ISBN: 978-1-900322-86-7